Criminal (Fiona Apple song)

"Criminal" is a song by American singer-songwriter Fiona Apple, released in September 1997 as the third single from her debut album, Tidal. Written and produced by Apple, the song is a piano-driven ballad that explores themes of guilt, shame, and exploitation within a relationship.

The lyrics detail the singer's awareness of her manipulative and damaging behavior towards her lover, portraying her as a flawed and morally ambiguous figure. She acknowledges her transgression, referring to herself as a criminal for the pain she has caused. The confessional tone and raw honesty of the lyrics resonated with audiences and critics, contributing to the song's widespread popularity.

"Criminal" is characterized by its haunting melody, Apple's distinctive vocal delivery, and its stark, confessional lyrical content. The song's arrangement features a prominent piano melody, subtle orchestration, and a building intensity throughout. It deviates from typical pop song structures, favoring a more atmospheric and introspective approach.

The accompanying music video, directed by Mark Romanek, generated significant controversy due to its portrayal of Apple in a state of semi-nudity and perceived heroin chic aesthetic. Despite the criticism, the video became iconic and further cemented Apple's image as an unconventional and artistically daring performer.

"Criminal" achieved significant commercial success, reaching the top 40 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart. It also won Apple a Grammy Award for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance in 1998. The song remains one of Apple's most recognizable and enduring works, and is considered a defining song of the 1990s alternative music scene. It has been praised for its lyrical complexity, musical innovation, and its willingness to explore darker and more complex themes.